Evaluate a management system
by

How To Evaluate A Management System

Choosing an agency management system is one of the most important business decisions you’ll make.

After decades of helping agencies through this process, I can tell you there are smart, effective ways to evaluate a system—and there are poor approaches that almost guarantee a bad decision.

Rule #1: Show Me, Don’t Tell Me

The Importance of a Walk-Through

Let’s be blunt: sales reps often exaggerate what their system can do. Some even stretch the truth.

Example: One vendor advertises “downloading.” But in reality, it only drops a text file into the policy—it doesn’t update the policy. That forces staff to manually update records, which defeats the purpose of downloading altogether.

If you simply ask, “Does your system offer downloading?” the salesperson will say “yes.” Without a walk-through, you won’t realize the feature is nearly useless until it’s too late.

The solution: Insist on seeing the system in action. During a walk-through, have the rep show you exactly how to:

  • Add a client.
  • Add a policy (with full detail).
  • Enter a B-Tran/Invoice.
  • Send an email.
  • Process an endorsement or renewal.
  • See how you stay on top of work in process and open policy tasks.

Pay attention to the steps, clicks, and workflow. How much jumping around does it require? How streamlined is the process?

🔑 Bottom line: A product should sell itself when you see it in action. Without a walk-through, you can’t make a fair determination if CP Manager—or any system—is right for your agency.

Next Step: After a walk-through, if you're still not convinced, the natural next step is a Test Drive. This is where you get either a 7-day or 30-day login to CP Manager where you and your staff can dig in and give CP Manager a real test drive and experience it for yourself.

Once you’ve had a walk-through and you’ve seen how the system works, the smartest next step is to get hands-on. Unfortunately, most vendors don’t allow this — they stop at the demo. That’s why I recommend asking if a system offers a test drive. It’s the only way to know if the workflows truly fit your agency. With CP Manager, we make this possible through both a 7-day and a 30-day Test Drive. Few vendors are willing to do that, but it’s the most reliable way to avoid an expensive mistake.

We’re one of the only vendors that offer this:

  • 7-Day Test Drive ($67): Shared demo agency.
  • 30-Day Test Drive ($197): Full control of your own setup, fee credited if you purchase.

Learn more about our Test Drive program.

Rule #2: It’s Not About Price—It’s About Productivity

A system’s real cost isn’t the subscription fee—it’s how much time it consumes (or saves) for your staff.

A “cheaper” system that requires 10% more CSR hours will cost your agency far more than you save upfront.

Remember:
Increased Productivity = Increased Profitability.

When evaluating a system, focus on:

  • Double-entry: Does data flow seamlessly, or must staff retype information?
  • Workflows: How many steps does it take to process policy tasks? How does the system help staff stay on top of work?
  • Ease of use: Is the system intuitive, or does it create a steep learning curve and painful transition?

📘 Want to dig deeper? Read: What "Increasing Your Productivity" Really Means to Your Agency and The Big Savings with CP Manager.

Rule #3: It’s Not About Features—It’s Still About Productivity

One of the biggest mistakes agencies make when evaluating a management system is getting distracted by feature lists.

Vendors love to overwhelm prospects with long, impressive catalogs of functions and features. And when they demo the system to agencies, they spend most of the time showing features to "wow" the agency and very little time showing how the system will help them handle their day-to-day work.

But here’s the reality: After talking to many agencies on these bloated systems, most agencies only use 15–20% of those features. Those features they were so impressed with ultimately end up not being used. That's because, when the rubber hits the road, your day-to-day work and increased productivity are what really matter!

This also means they’re paying for a system full of things they don’t use and will likely never need or use.

And worse, all those extra bells and whistles often make the system harder to learn, harder to use, and slower for your staff. Instead of making your team more productive, bloated systems actually create drag.

The real question isn’t “Who has the most features?” The real question is:
👉 “Which system helps my staff get their work done faster and more accurately every single day?”

That’s why the smartest agencies focus on:

  • How the system handles core workflows (adding policies, renewals, endorsements).
  • How much double-entry there is.
  • How easy it is to train new staff.
  • How much time it actually saves per CSR per month.

Features don’t drive profitability. Productivity does.

An agency that saves 35 hours per CSR per month (a 20% productivity boost) will see a far bigger financial return than one that bought the system with the thickest feature catalog but increase the time for every task.

👉 Remember: Increased productivity equals increased profitability. That’s the true measure of a great system.

The CP Manager Review Process

We offer multiple ways to review CP Manager—many without ever speaking to an account manager. Some resources require sharing your information first. Why?

Because CP Manager is unique. It was built from over 30 years of industry experience, combining deep workflow knowledge, programming expertise, and an obsession with productivity. No other vendor has invested the time or money we have to create a true productivity-driven system. Protecting these innovations is essential.

When you do speak with an account manager, you’ll find we’re respectful and not pushy. Our goal is simple:

  • Learn what’s important to you.
  • Recommend the most efficient review path based on your timeline.
  • Help you decide confidently if CP Manager is the right fit.

👉 Let's have a discussion and talk about these 3 points. Let's determine if CP Manager is a good fit or isn't the right fit for your agency upfront to save both of us time.